Anything about JUDAISM
Anything about JUDAISM
profile | register | search


This is an archived site, for new discussion please see JewsWithQuestions.com
Forums | | Post Reply Send Topic To a Friend
Author Topic
shannny Posted - 23 April 2001 20:50
Is it wrong for a teenage girl to wear makeup?
MODERATOR Posted - 23 April 2001 21:33
Depends what age, what community, and what kind of makeup.

When we say something is "good looking" it means different things in different contexts. WHen we say "That's a beautiful mountain", "beautiful" means "majestic"; a "beautiful deer" means graceful; abeautiful lion "means powerful and royal"; a "beautiful slapshot" means "fast and hard"; a "beautiful computer" means "sleek and modernistic".

When we say "a beautiful woman", we dont mean she looks like a space ship, like we would mean when we say the new Panasonic boon box is a "beautiful machine."

We mean one thing: This woman is attractive to men.

The things that make women "beautiful", including being young-looking, are those things that attract men to them. Logically, there is nothgin more beautiful about a young woman than an old woman, considering that an old woman represents wisdom, experience, accomplishment, and honor. But she's not as attractive to men.

And, it is also a fact: Makeup is designed to make girls more attractive to men. It makes your eyes bigger than they really are, your lips redder, your cheekbones higher, and to hide various physical imperfections.

For a girl to say "I am not interested in looking attractive to men; Im just interested in looking beautiful", she is contradicting herself.

Now theres nothing wrong with a woman being beautiful, including attractive to men. Its the way Hashem made her. But now the question is, is there anything wrong with a teenage girl artificially enhancing her looks in a way that all that changed is now she is mroe attractive to men.

Is it right for a 15 year old to do that?

Obviously not. But the problem is, in today's secualr society, women have become objectified to the point where it is considered almost weird not to wear makeup, even at age 15, since it is soooooo a part of secular society that girls are expected to want to attract guys.

Thats why guys dont wear makeup. Seriously. Makeup would make men more attractive to women and movie stars always wear makeup on the set. And when you see a picture of a celebrity caught on the street without his makeup, he definitely looks much more blah.

But because society, for whatever reason, emphasizes looks more by women than men and so women are expected to be "look" perfect, while men can still get away by being judged by their "attitude".

But whatever. So really, girls have no reason to wear makeup until theyre of marriagable age, after which they indeed would like to look more attractive to men. Otherwise, it doesnt accomplish anything, except make the girl more comfortable in a society that declared that sexiness is "normal attire" for women. Unfortunately, we Yidden cannot accomodate that kind of societal demands. We have our own society.

We hope. So here's the story: If a girl is living in a Torah society she has zero reason to wear makeup unti shes ready to start attracting guys. If shes living among a very secular society, I would not pick this as my battle. If she has the guts and the strength to walk around different than everyone else, then more strength to her! If not, I would definitely not force such a rule in a community where every 15 year old girl is walking around with makeup. You have to know where your people are holding.

ptgard2281 Posted - 24 April 2001 3:07
That's not true, though. Girls do have reasons other than to impress guys. What about girls who lack self confidence or feel like they are ugly? What about those who are going somewhere to make an impression for a job interview? I mean, there are dozens of reasons other than to impress the guys. They should viably be allowed to wear makeup.
MODERATOR Posted - 24 April 2001 3:12
I didnt say the motivation of the girls is to impress guys. I said the definition of beauty, in the sense that make-up makes them beautiful, is that they are more successful in impressing guys.

So if a girl feels ugly without makeup and pretty with makeup, and therefore she feels "bad" about herself, it means that unless she has the abiltiy to attract guys she will feel bad about herself. This is true because objectively, the only thing the makeup did for her was give her that ability.

It did not make her look wiser, more experienced, a better person, etc., all of which could define "prettiness". The problem is not her intention but her perspective, that being able to artificially enhance your face so that you can attract guys (thats all makeup does) makes you feel better.

The solution is for her to get a perspective on what ought to make a person feel good and whats "hevel hevolim".

The job interview may be a legitimate reason to wear makeup, depending on the situation, the age of the girl, etc. But thats not what these schools who prohibit makeup are talking about.

Edited by - admindealing on 4/23/2001 11:13:52 PM

shannny Posted - 24 April 2001 19:17
Do you really think that girls wear makeup to impress guys, b/c that sure seems like what you're saying? There's no isur in looking good and that basically what a girl is trying to do when she wears makeup. Lets say a girl go to an all girls camp, is it then permissible to wear makeup?
MODERATOR Posted - 24 April 2001 19:53
No, thats not what Im saying. Im NOT saying that the reason girls wear makeup is to impress guys. No, no, no.

I agree with you that girls wear makeup to look good.

But the question is, what kind of "good looks" does makeup give a girl, because there are many different kinds of "good looks".

A lion who "looks good" means powerful, or majestic. A skinny lion does NOT look good.

A rabbi who "looks good" means a Hadras Panim that makes him appear to be a Tzadik. A rabbi's "looks" are enhanced, let's say, with a long flowing beard.

A mountain that "looks good" means awe inspiring and tremendous. A petite mountain is a loser, looks-wise.

So "good looks" can mean many things. What does it mean when we say a girl all made up is more "good looking" than a girl with a bare face?

Majestic? Powerful? Awe inspiring? No.

How about wise? Experienced? She looks more like a baalas midos? Also no.

What exactly does makeup enhance about your looks? Specifically?

Theres only one thing makeup makes you look: More attractive to guys. Not richer, not smarter, not even healthier (on the contrary - nowadays, the minimal-to-no-makeup look is considered healthy, like on the cover of those herbal magazines).

It makes you look sexier, thats all.

Now when girls put on makeup, they dont think about this, because its so ingrained in their heads that makeup somehow makes you "look better". And it does, in a way. Just now you know which way.

And thats the problem. To secular society, thats the definition of "good looking", that is, attractive to guys. So when a secular person says "I want to be more good looking", the default value of that statement means she wants to look more appealiing to the opposite sex. Theyre so into sex, the Goyim, that when they say "good looking" thats what it means to them. And to them, theres nothing wrong with that. Thats what their main reason for "looking good" is.

But should we share that definition of "good looking"? When a Bas Yisroel says "I want to improve my looks" thats fine, but the question is, In what way do you want your looks to improve?

Again, the terms "pretty", "good looking", "better looking" are all ambiguous and mean something different when referring to different things.

So what does it mean when referring to you?

If makeup is what makes you look better, then looking better means one thing.

So the issue is not if it is assur to look good. The issue is what is there about high cheekbones that are "better looking" than lower ones? Is it healthier? Wiser? or more attractive to guys?

Same thing with shiny lips or blueish eyelids. What's "good looking" about blueish eyelids?

Only one thing.

No, I am not saying at all that girls want to attract guys so they put on makeup. Not at all. Especially since little girls like 8 and 9 think they "look good" in makeup too. But I am saying that we are so brainwashed by society's definition of "good looking" that we accept it without thinking about what it means and what looking good is actually good for.

There is nothign wrong with looking good. And there is nothing wrong with even being attractive to guys - thats the way Hashem made you. But if youre interested in Tznius it means not to go out of your way to make yourself even more attractive to guys by painting dark lines around your eyes and lips, painting your face to make believe your cheek bones are higher, and coloring your eyelids with unnatural color.

Lipstick emphasizes your lips, attracting attention to them, nothing more. Is that "good looking"? What do you think girls gain by attracting attention to their lips except if its guys' attention that theyre attracting? In what other context does attracting attention to your lips have any meaning at all?

Thats nto why youre doing it - youre doign it because society convinced you that that's generically "good looking". But what society says is good-looking is not at all generic. It means one thing.

All Im asking is that you think of what these specific types of enhancements to your looks accomplishes. It does not make you look healthier or wiser or stronger or sweeter. And then understand what is DOES do to your looks. And even though thats not what you intend, thats whats happening. And the reason we dont realize it is because were so brainwashed by secular society - the part of it thats so into sex - that we accept, without thinking, their philosophy of what "good looking" is.

alex123 Posted - 24 April 2001 21:53
If men shouldn't marry woman based on their looks, why is there even a need to wear makeup when you reach a marriagable age? Hopefully, your husband is marrying you for who you are, not for your looks. So, why is makeup neccesary then?
MODERATOR Posted - 24 April 2001 21:55
A man should not marry an otherwise inappropriate girl on the basis of jer looks, but he is surely allowed to seek out a good girl that is also attractive.
growinggirl Posted - 24 April 2001 22:16
ok- what about a bais yaakov girl who's goal is not to attract boys- but rather to look nice- because despite what you say- i still have to persist in saying that girls do want to look good- not just to attract guys. what about to look good for future shidduchim? when ppl look at you now- they'll remember you- and don't say that looks dont' matter- because when ppl look at shidduch prospects, they do take the physical aspects into consideration.and also- of "marriagble age" doesn't just have to be 18. ppl remember girls from when they are 15 and 16. i know because i've seen this.
MODERATOR Posted - 24 April 2001 22:19
You probably wrote your post before I posted my last one. I didnt say BY girls wear makeup to attract guys. The remembering about a shiduch thing is rare, and it can be more damaging if they remember that she wore makeup at 15. In any case, its not a reason to wear makeup now, because of the slight chance that in 4 years someones gonna remember seeing you.
shannny Posted - 25 April 2001 2:13
You gave a very impressive answer, but didnt answer the part about going to an all girl's camp where clearly you dont want to look sexy or look good in the eyes of boys because there are none. You do it because it's fun to sometimes wear makeup and you want to also look good once in a while in the eyes of your peers. Can you wear makeup there? Also can you wear makeup to a chusunah? Everyone gets dressed up from chasunos and look good mainly for the kalah herself.
growinggirl Posted - 25 April 2001 23:37
you're right--- i did write my reply before i read that last one- and thank you for clarifying because it makes sense. but does that mean that a girl who wants to do what is right should stop wearing makeup? what if it helps her self esteem?
MODERATOR Posted - 25 April 2001 23:57
shanny,

In an all girls camp you go swimming in front of each other, so how can wearing makeup in front of each other be worse?

But the issue still remains that by thinking you look "better" in makeup, you are accepting the secular notion that how "good" you look depends on how much your looks can attract guys. Even if no guys are around, youre still using that criterion as youryardstick for how good you look.

The idea is to reach the level where you will consider "good looking" to mean that you look happier and healthier, as opposed to "more attractive". Its a philosophy issue more than a Tznius issue, in an all-girl's camp.


The same thing applies to "growinggirl". If you want to do the "right thing", change your attitude about what "good looking" means. Then you wont want to wear makeup until the proper time.

hi Posted - 26 April 2001 0:34
I find it very hard to believe that people dress up for a wedding and put on make-up (to quote"Everyone gets dressed up from chasunos and look good mainly for the kalah herself.")for the Kallah. Do you think the Kallah is happier when she sees you wearing make-up?? Why? The only time I can imagine a Kallah being happy seeing someone wearing make-up, is if she sees a girl that needs help taking care of herself and always looks unpresentable, and then if she sees her wearing make-up at her wedding she might feel happy that the girl got the help she needed. Please be honest with yourself and ask yourself if the make-up will make the kallah happy. I am not saying anything against wearing make-up at a wedding. I just don't like the reasoning given above.
shannny Posted - 26 April 2001 1:48
yes i do think it makes the kallah happy to see a girl all dressed up and looking really nice at her wedding.
ptgard2281 Posted - 26 April 2001 3:40
Mod, you are giving a valid answer, but I think you are subjecting your answer to your own personal opinions. That could be your definition of beauty and what a girl does to make herself pretty, etc. As a female, though, I completely disagree -- I think that when I don't wear makeup in many situations, I look messy . . . the makeup helps put my face together just as a well tailored suit. If I am wearing a great suit without the makeup, I might look like I was too lazy to complete the outfit.
Topic is 4 Pages Long:    1 2 3 4

Click Here To Close Thread, Administrators & Moderators Only.

Show All Forums | Post Reply